KB280

夏俊峰案,莫以同情的名义助推“暴戾”氛围

530阅读 | 0回复

发表于 2013/10/8 13:43:31| 收藏

[楼主]

 

 

  9月25日,经最高人民法院核准,夏俊峰被依法执行死刑。然而,搅动舆论场的“小贩刺死城管案”远没有结束,反而引来更为激烈的争论。


  小贩夏俊峰被执行死刑,因其弱势群体的身份标签,和身后留下的孤儿寡母,给不少人带来一种悲情,我们试着去分析悲情和争论中存在的问题。


  首先,舆论中的强弱相对。夏俊峰是小贩,是舆论关注的弱势群体,城管却是执法中的强势群体。然而,太多的人只关注了强弱交锋,却放逐了交锋起因。城市小摊贩究竟要不要管理?城市小摊贩要不要遵守法律、规章、制度?似乎在争论中这是不需要回应的话题。


  其次,情感中的生离死别。夏俊峰为人夫,为人父,是家里的顶梁柱,有一个聪明爱画的孩子。夏俊峰的死,是一个家庭的悲剧。然而,太多人的只关注了一个家庭的悲剧,却放逐了另外两个家庭的离别。城管也有家庭,被刺死的两位城管,他们的家属和孩子,难道不值得同情?难道不值得人们去关心?似乎在争论中也是不需要关注的话题。


  最后,法律中的孰是孰非。夏俊峰案事发2009年5月,到如今,案件已历时4年之久,如果不是事实清楚,证据充分,最高人民法院也不会轻率作出死刑的判决。国有国法,该不该有法必依?似乎争论中也是不需要考虑的话题。


  在现代文明社会,任何人都不能以剥夺他人生命来发泄自己的情绪,夏俊峰刺死两名执法城管、重伤一人,最终他也被依法执行死刑,这彰显的是法律的公平公正。故意杀人者理应面对刑罚,暴力不值得提倡,更不应给予掌声。作为现代公民,我们不该让同情去代替理性思考,更不应该被情绪左右而失去客观的分析和判断。我们更应该去思考这案子背后折射出的社会管理、暴戾之气等处于社会转型期的中国问题。


  城管是否有存在价值,当然有值得讨论的地方。但可以推定的是,一刀切取消城管,并不是所有深受无序经营摊贩之扰的市民所期望的。这就有值得深思的地方,究竟是什么引起了“城管”与“摊贩”交恶的众怒?城管粗鲁执法是其一,但媒体不报城管依法管理只报恃强凌弱信息是不是其一?一些憎恶管理制度的观点幻化成对抗公权的“公义”是不是其一?


  通过夏俊峰案,我们看到媒体对推动社会进步、创新社会管理方面的反思不那么多,看到的却是在煽情炒作夏俊峰案,丝毫不顾及此案中那些死者的家属及孩子的悲痛之情,有的还试图违背社会基本价值观去塑造暴力“英雄”,这似乎有悖于媒体的理性、客观和公正态度。


  殊不知,出于同情心泛滥而宽容罪行,并以此占据道德制高点为暴力犯罪辩护,只能助长更多极端情绪的爆发,形成更大负面的“示范效应”,从而让更多公众的生命安全蒙受无妄之灾。我们的媒体,切莫成为推动社会“暴戾”的帮凶,而应秉承公平公正的角度去报道社会热点,以客观和理性去推动社会文明和进步。

 

 

cost of abortion west-bot.com statistics about abortion
statistics on abortion abortion pill price 12 weeks pregnant abortion
my boyfriend cheated on me but i still love him i had a dream that my boyfriend cheated on me how to cheat boyfriend
my boyfriend cheated on me but i still love him i had a dream that my boyfriend cheated on me how to cheat boyfriend
want to cheat on my wife read so your wife cheated on you
unfaithful spouse catch a cheat all wives cheat
why women cheat women who love to cheat why some women cheat
chemical abortion http://abortionpill-online.com how can i do abortion
chemical abortion http://abortionpill-online.com how can i do abortion
amoxicillin pill zithromax ciprofloxacin 500mg
revia 50mg click prednisolone 10mg
lisinopril and bph lisinopril and bph lisinopril and bph
cialis sample coupon click discount coupons for prescriptions
cialis sample coupon prescription drug discount cards discount coupons for prescriptions
online cialis coupons free prescription drug cards prescription coupon card
free discount prescription card prostudiousa.com discount prescription coupons
free discount prescription card prostudiousa.com discount prescription coupons
free discount prescription card cialis coupons online discount prescription coupons
cialis cvs coupon read cialis
amoxicillin wiki read amoxicilline
nexium forum blog.martinhey.de nexium esomeprazol
buscopan u porodu click buscopan compositum
propecia 0.5 mg site propecia tabletta
prescriptions coupons acantheschool.com cialis coupon card
prescriptions coupons read cialis coupon card
kamagranow open kamagra prix
cialis walgreen coupon francescocutolo.it cialis
coupons cialis thestickybeak.co.uk cialis savings and coupons
coupons cialis thestickybeak.co.uk cialis savings and coupons
coupons cialis thestickybeak.co.uk cialis savings and coupons
free coupon for cialis adlerhohenems.com cialis online coupon
cialis coupons from lilly coupon for free cialis cialis coupons from manufacturer
abortion pill cost without insurance the abortion pill cost types of abortion pill
amoxicillin amoxicillin amoxicillin nedir
abortion pill video should abortion pill be legal how much do abortion pill cost
abortion pill video abortion pill complications how much do abortion pill cost
how much are abortions different types of abortion pill early abortion pill options
average abortion pill cost cost of abortions average cost of an abortion pill
voltaren krem fiyat voltaren retard voltaren retard
history of abortion pill amazonschools.com abortion pill laws
amoxicillin endikasyonlar amoxicillin 500 mg amoxicillin al 1000
feldene ampolla feldene d feldene gel
cialis discounts coupons bangzontheweb.com free cialis coupon 2016
vermox doziranje by-expression.com vermox
nootropil review nootropil piracetam nootropil 1200
clomid cycle clomid proviron clomid proviron
cialis 2015 coupon cialis discount coupons cialis coupon
ldn benefits go ldn for dogs
ldn website link implant for drug addiction
low dose naltrexone ulcerative colitis link what is naltrexone made of
revia medicine read narcan challenge test

本帖最后编辑时间发表于 2013/10/8 13:43:31